The Human Experience · Episode

Episode 183 – Oliver Burkeman – Happiness for people who can’t stand positive thinking

A conversation with Oliver Burkeman

Oliver Burkeman is an award-winning feature writer for The Guardian and the author of The Antidote: Happiness for People Who Can’t Stand Positive Thinking, published by Faber & Faber in 2012.

Published
September 30, 2022
Runtime
52:23
Play52:23

Episode field notes

Show notes

Oliver Burkeman is an award-winning feature writer for The Guardian and the author of The Antidote: Happiness for People Who Can’t Stand Positive Thinking, published by Faber & Faber in 2012. He lives in New York City.

Oliver joined The Guardian in 2000, working primarily on magazine features and as a columnist. His most widely read journalism is his weekly column on psychology, productivity and the science of happiness, entitled This Column Will Change Your Life. (A collection of these columns was published in the UK in 2011, entitled Help!: How To Become Slightly Happier and Get a Bit More Done.) His other reporting has taken him to the extreme north of Canada (to investigate the battle for natural resources under the Arctic Sea); to the slums outside Nairobi (to report on the real-world effects of celebrity anti-poverty campaigns); and to rural Sweden (to report on the rise and rise of the IKEA empire). He has interviewed a wide range of high-profile figures, including Bill Clinton, Al Gore, Jimmy Carter, David Cameron, Dolly Parton, 50 Cent, and Larry David.

Oliver has spoken extensively – on themes such as the problems with overfocusing on goals, the upsides of uncertainty in business, finding time for creative work, and ancient Stoicism as a philosophy for modern life – at events including: the 99U Conference at Lincoln Center in New York; the Edinburgh International Book Festival; the World Knowledge Forum in Seoul, South Korea; the creativity conference Adobe MAX in Los Angeles; and The Guardian ’s Masterclass series and at the School Of Life in London. His radio appearances have included NPR’s All Things Considered, BBC Radio 4’s Today program, and WNYC’s The Leonard Lopate Show, and he is working on two BBC radio programs on psychology to be broadcast in 2016.

Oliver has written for The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, The New Republic, New Philosopher, Salon, Slate, Newsweek/The Daily Beast, and Esquire. He writes a monthly column in Psychologies magazine, published in the UK.

Oliver holds an MA in Social and Political Sciences from Cambridge University. He grew up in York, in the north of England, where it rains a lot.

The Antidote: Happiness for People Who Can’t Stand Positive Thinking , his latest book, is an exploration of the upsides of uncertainty, pessimism, failure and insecurity – part philosophical investigation, part first-person travelogue. (The research included a grueling silent meditation retreat, and a trip to one of Mexico City’s most dangerous neighborhoods.) The Antidote introduces a disparate group of people – psychologists, terrorism experts, spiritual teachers, and business consultants – who share a single, surprising way of thinking about life. They argue that ‘positive thinking’, relentless optimism, and a fixation on ambitious goal-setting often aren’t the solution, but part of the problem – and that there is an alternative, ‘negative path’ to happiness and success that involves embracing the very things we spend our lives trying to avoid. The Antidote was an Amazon Editors’ Pick for Best Books of November 2012, and extracts or related op-eds have featured in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, Salon and Slate. In a starred review, Kirkus Reviews called it “a fascinating, wide-ranging exploration of negativity, positivity, failure, success and what it means to be happy,” with “the potential to effect genuine, lasting changes.”The Los Angeles Times described it as “deeply insightful and entertaining.”

The Antidote: Happiness for People Who Can’t Stand Positive Thinking:

Success through failure, calm through embracing anxiety―a totally original approach to self-help

Self-help books don’t seem to work. Few of the many advantages of modern life seem capable of lifting our collective mood. Wealth―even if you can get it―doesn’t necessarily lead to happiness. Romance, family life, and work often bring as much stress as joy. We can’t even agree on what “happiness” means. So are we engaged in a futile pursuit? Or are we just going about it the wrong way?
Looking both east and west, in bulletins from the past and from far afield, Oliver Burkeman introduces us to an unusual group of people who share a single, surprising way of thinking about life. Whether experimental psychologists, terrorism experts, Buddhists, hardheaded business consultants, Greek philosophers, or modern-day gurus, they argue that in our personal lives, and in society at large, it’s our constant effort to be happy that is making us miserable. And that there is an alternative path to happiness and success that involves embracing failure, pessimism, insecurity, and uncertainty―the very things we spend our lives trying to avoid. Thought-provoking, counterintuitive, and ultimately uplifting,The Antidote is the intelligent person’s guide to understanding the much-misunderstood idea of happiness.

antidote

click to purchase

In this episode we spoke to Oliver Burkeman in which we covered the self help industry, guru worship, social media mis-haps and much much more – this is a hilariously fun packed episode.  

This conversation will challenge your ideas regarding positive thinking. 

Find Oliver and his work Visit oliverburkeman.com.

Find Oliver’s work at The Guardian Visit theguardian.com

on Twitter:@oliverburkeman

We rely on listener support to keep this show AD FREE – If you value even one of our shows, help us sustain and scale the show up; Become a member  for 5$/mo (a cup of coffee) or Donate.

Read the complete recording

Transcript

Existing transcript, with its original wording and timestamps. Automated transcripts may contain errors.

[00:00:01] I'm Oliver burkeman and my book is
[00:00:03] I'm Oliver burkeman and my book is called the antidote happiness for people
[00:00:05] called the antidote happiness for people who can't stand positive thinking it's
[00:00:07] who can't stand positive thinking it's the story of my Adventures among some
[00:00:08] the story of my Adventures among some
[00:00:09] people who have a really unexpected and
[00:00:10] people who have a really unexpected and I think potentially revolutionary take
[00:00:12] I think potentially revolutionary take on how we think about happiness and
[00:00:14] on how we think about happiness and success which is in short that too much
[00:00:16] success which is in short that too much focus on positivity and optimism is the
[00:00:19] focus on positivity and optimism is the problem not the answer so here's a good
[00:00:22] problem not the answer so here's a good place to start there's an old game that
[00:00:24] place to start there's an old game that involves getting hold of one of your
[00:00:25] involves getting hold of one of your friends and challenging them to not
[00:00:26] friends and challenging them to not think about a polar bear for a whole
[00:00:28] think about a polar bear for a whole minute of course they can't do it try it
[00:00:31] minute of course they can't do it try it for yourself as soon as you make the
[00:00:32] for yourself as soon as you make the effort all you can think of is polar
[00:00:34] effort all you can think of is polar bears it's the fact that you're trying
[00:00:36] bears it's the fact that you're trying so hard to do something that sabotages
[00:00:38] so hard to do something that sabotages your attempt to do it I think that's a
[00:00:40] your attempt to do it I think that's a good analogy for the whole book it seems
[00:00:42] good analogy for the whole book it seems so obvious to most people that if you
[00:00:43] so obvious to most people that if you want to be happy you should do lots of
[00:00:45] want to be happy you should do lots of positive thinking that if you want to be
[00:00:46] positive thinking that if you want to be successful you should set clear goals
[00:00:49] successful you should set clear goals that in general you should cultivate
[00:00:50] that in general you should cultivate optimism and above all avoid thinking
[00:00:52] optimism and above all avoid thinking about the fact that in the end you're
[00:00:54] about the fact that in the end you're going to die but there's a lot of really
[00:00:56] going to die but there's a lot of really exciting psychological research that's
[00:00:58] exciting psychological research that's turning all that on its head it's
[00:01:00] turning all that on its head it's emerged for example that those books of
[00:01:01] emerged for example that those books of positive thinking affirmations often
[00:01:03] positive thinking affirmations often make people miserable and that
[00:01:04] make people miserable and that visualizing your goals can make you less
[00:01:06] visualizing your goals can make you less likely to achieve them because your
[00:01:08] likely to achieve them because your brain relaxes it gets tricked into
[00:01:09] brain relaxes it gets tricked into thinking that you've already achieved
[00:01:10] thinking that you've already achieved
[00:01:11] the goal and it turns out that there's a
[00:01:13] the goal and it turns out that there's a long tradition in philosophy and
[00:01:14] long tradition in philosophy and spirituality that's about embracing
[00:01:17] spirituality that's about embracing negativity about easing up on all this
[00:01:19] negativity about easing up on all this positive thinking and learning instead
[00:01:21] positive thinking and learning instead to bathe in insecurity and uncertainty
[00:01:23] to bathe in insecurity and uncertainty and failure to confront your mortality
[00:01:26] and failure to confront your mortality and to find the enormous potential for
[00:01:27] and to find the enormous potential for happiness that's lurking inside all that
[00:01:30] happiness that's lurking inside all that so in the book I I meet modern day
[00:01:32] so in the book I I meet modern day stoics who argue that you should often
[00:01:33] stoics who argue that you should often focus on the worst case scenario instead
[00:01:35] focus on the worst case scenario instead of the best I go on a silent Buddhist
[00:01:38] of the best I go on a silent Buddhist Meditation Retreat I travel to Mexico
[00:01:40] Meditation Retreat I travel to Mexico and Kenya and elsewhere to try to find
[00:01:42] and Kenya and elsewhere to try to find people who have this radical take on
[00:01:44] people who have this radical take on happiness and success and I think what
[00:01:46] happiness and success and I think what emerges is actually a really happy
[00:01:48] emerges is actually a really happy message especially for people like me
[00:01:50] message especially for people like me who've always been quite put off by
[00:01:51] who've always been quite put off by positive thinking and motivational
[00:01:53] positive thinking and motivational speakers and all the rest of it and
[00:01:55] speakers and all the rest of it and that's that as individuals and as a
[00:01:57] that's that as individuals and as a society we can ReDiscover the power of
[00:01:59] society we can ReDiscover the power of negative thinking
[00:02:02] negative thinking
Original recording

About the guest

Oliver Burkeman

Oliver Burkeman is an award-winning feature writer for The Guardian and the author of The Antidote: Happiness for People Who Can’t Stand Positive Thinking, published by Faber & Faber in 2012. He lives in New York City.

View all 2 appearances

The HXP dispatch

Carry the question with you.

New conversations, essential ideas, and recommendations worth your attention—sent thoughtfully.

Private by design. No spam. Leave whenever you like.

Independent conversations

Help make the next one possible.

Membership sustains ambitious, unhurried interviews and keeps the complete archive open to curious listeners everywhere.

Become a member